Since 2004, Fabio Capello had taken over the club, and lead them to two more Serie A titles. But during May 2006, Juventus were one of four clubs (along with AC Milan, Fiorentina, and Lazio) linked to a Serie A match fixing scandal. At the center of the accusations was Juventus general manager Luciano Moggi, who was accused of influencing referees and even the false imprisonment of one; no players were accused of any wrong-doing. Moggi along with two other members of the board resigned on May 13. The clubs involved were ordered to stand trial, around this time Gianluca Pessotto almost lost his life when he fell from a 4th story window, the media suggested that it could have been a suicide attempt because of the stress of trial.[23]
Manager Capello, left for Real Madrid before the verdict had been handed out. FIGC prosecutor Stefano Palazzi called the four clubs to be thrown out of Serie A and that Juventus have their last two title’s stripped.[24] The sentences saw Juventus stripped of two titles, and relegated to Serie B for the first time in their history.[25] The club was also docked 30 points for the 2006-2007 season, which was reduced to 17 points and finally 9 points after an appeal. Numerous players left the club, including European Footballer of the Year and 2006 World Cup winning captain, Fabio Cannavaro, Lillian Thuram, Gianluca Zambrotta, Patrick Vieira and Zlatan Ibrahimović, the latter two players sold to rivals Inter for €34.3 million. However, some highly rated players remained loyal; Gianluigi Buffon, captain Alessandro Del Piero, Pavel Nedvěd, Mauro Camoranesi and David Trézéguet.
After the initial verdicts were handed out, the club continued to launch appeals to re-instate them in Serie A along with their lost titles, going as far as filing in Italian civil court [26], a move that violated FIFA administrative rules and threatened the club more sanctions from FIGC[26]. The team dropped its civil suit before it went to trial, opting for the Italian Olympic Committee, to review its case[26]. The team were unsuccessful in reacquiring its lost titles, but it did manage to have its points deduction reduced from 30 to nine. Since the trial, Juventus officials have derided the decision, citing in its civil appeal of “favourtism” against both Inter (who won Juventus’ lost 2005-06 title) and Messina (who remained in Serie A in place of Juventus)[26] and calling the decision to hand Inter their 2005-06 scudetto “incomprehensible”[27]. The allegations against Inter are not without merit, as the official in charge of appointing the referees (Paolo Bergamo) believed Inter should have been punished too[28] and developments after the scandal broke showed Inter may have had a bigger role in the scandal than previously known.
In 2007, the club was threatened to be involved again in the scandal after the Calciopoli investigators finished their probe[29]. Among the new evidence was a 0-0 draw with Milan on 18 December 2004, where Milan claimed two penalties were missed and a free kick awarded while in attack, which, upon learning of this evidence, Milan sought to sue for the 2005 title[30]. Eventually, investigators decided to bring charges to 37 people- most of whom were already convicted in the previous investigation- but no new charges against Juventus.